Orange Creamsicle Icebox Pie -

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

This creamy orange and vanilla icebox pie is inspired by the famous ice cream treat we loved when we were kids! No bake, no egg-quick and easy!

I remember every Sunday around 6:30 pm, hearing the music from the ice cream truck...I'd run through the house screaming, "I NEED A DIME" like the house was on fire!

It was a critical issue to find a dime FAST...because the ice cream man was out front RIGHT NOW...and two nickels wouldn't suffice...I needed a DIME for a Creamsicle.

That dreamy sugary concoction on a stick...orange and vanilla, swirled together...oh, what a treat it was then, and still is today!

Why you'll love this:

No baking...just combine the ingredients and pour it into a prepared graham cracker pie shell
No eggs - just cream cheese, orange jello, vanilla and sweet condensed milk
Perfect for summer - this chilled, light icebox pie is heavenly on a hot day

Here's what you'll need for Orange Creamsicle Icebox Pie:

How to make it:

Chill a prepared graham cracker pie crust
Pour gelatin granules into ¼ cup cold tap water; do not stir; let sit for 15-minutes
Combine cream cheese, sweet condensed milk and vanilla extract in food processor, stand mixer or use a hand-mixer until smooth
Add gelatin mixture and mix on low for a second or two - not too long
Pour mixture into chilled pie shell
Freeze for 4 hours; move pie from freezer to fridge about 30-minutes before you want to serve it (this lets the crust thaw, which makes slicing the pie easier.

Tips:

Chill the crust - I put it in the freezer for about 30-minutes
Soften the cream cheese - room temperature
Mix the orange gelatin granules with water - let it sit for 15-minutes; don't stir it
Freeze the pie - when ready to serve, move it from the freezer to the fridge; let it sit in the fridge for about 15 minutes; if you don't let the crust thaw in the fridge, it sticks to the pie plate
Use a warm knife to slice the cold pie - for a super clean slice, use a sharp butcher knife; run it under hot water for a few minutes; dry the knife, then stick the tip of the knife in the center of the pie and move the knife back...don't lower the handle to "slice" it-- just use the tip of the knife and drag it towards you
After you've made one slice; run the knife under warm water again; dry; slice; repeat
If your icebox pie gets runny, put it back in the refrigerator
Graham cracker pie crust: I find the ones in the store work just fine, but they're too skimpy so, I buy two crusts; take them out of the aluminum pan and crumble them up in a big bowl; melt a stick of butter; drizzle the butter over the crumbs; combine well
Pour buttered crumbs into your own 9"inch pie shell; using your fingers, pat the crumb mixture-packing it into a glass pie plate
If you're worried about serving "pretty slices," you might want to use small, individual 4-ounce graham cracker tart shells; this pie makes 2 cups of filling (16 ounces) so you'd need 4-6 individual shells

Orange Creamsicle Pie garnished with whipped cream edging and mandarin oranges — *Orange Creamsicle Icebox Pie is perfect for summer!*

Related recipes:

Shared at Meal Plan Monday